Grammar Shortcuts, Lesson 4: "Who" vs. "Whom"
Choosing between who and whom becomes incredibly simple if you use the he/him method. Because who is a subject pronoun, it matches perfectly with he. Because whom is an object pronoun, it matches perfectly with him. Whenever you are stuck, rephrase the question or clause as a statement using he or him to find the right answer.
_____ wrote the letter? (Turn it into a statement: He wrote the letter. Since he fits, the correct choice is Who wrote the letter?)
For _____ should I vote? (Turn it into a statement: Should I vote for him? Since him fits, the correct choice is For whom should I vote?)
When dealing with longer sentences, you must isolate the specific clause containing the choice to apply the test properly.
We all know _____ pulled that prank. (Isolate the second clause: _____ pulled that prank. Test it: He pulled that prank. Therefore, the correct choice is Who pulled that prank.)
We want to know on _____ the prank was pulled. (Isolate the second clause and rearrange it: The prank was pulled on _____. Test it: The prank was pulled on him. Therefore, the correct choice is on whom the prank was pulled.)
Cracking the Code: “Whoever” vs. “Whomever”
To determine whether to use whoever or whomever, you can expand the text into two distinct test sentences using he and him. Once you have your two pronouns, apply this simple mathematical formula: him + he = whoever, while him + him = whomever.
Give it to _____ asks for it first. (Test 1: Give it to him. Test 2: He asks for it first. Since you have a him and a he, they combine to give you whoever asks for it first.)
We will hire _____ you recommend. (Test 1: We will hire him. Test 2: You recommend him. Since you have two him pronouns, they combine to give you whomever you recommend.)
We will hire _____ is most qualified. (Test 1: We will hire him. Test 2: He is most qualified. The combination of him and he gives you whoever is most qualified.)
A secondary rule applies when an entire clause acts as the subject of a following verb. In these cases, you must look strictly inside the clause itself to determine the correct pronoun based on whether it is performing or receiving the action within that bubble.
Whoever is elected will serve a four-year term. (The entire clause Whoever is elected is the subject of will serve, but inside the clause, Whoever is the subject of is elected.)
Whomever you elect will serve a four-year term. (The entire clause Whomever you elect is the subject of will serve, but inside the clause, Whomever acts as the object being elected by you.)
The Deciding Line: “Who,” “That,” and “Which”
When choosing relative pronouns, you must first distinguish between people and objects. The pronoun who is reserved exclusively for people, while that and which refer to inanimate objects, things, or collective groups.
Anya is the one who rescued the bird. (Refers to a person)
Lokua is on the team that won first place. (Refers to a collective group)
She belongs to an organization that specializes in saving endangered species. (Refers to an entity)
Structural Anchors: Essential vs. Nonessential Clauses
The choice between that and which comes down to whether the information is vital to the sentence. The pronoun that introduces an essential clause, meaning the sentence would lose its core meaning without it. These clauses are never surrounded by commas. Conversely, which introduces a nonessential clause, which merely adds bonus details to a noun that is already fully identified. These clauses must always be surrounded by commas.
I do not trust editorials that claim racial differences in intelligence. (Without the that clause, the reader would have no idea which specific editorials are being distrusted, making the information essential.)
The editorial claiming racial differences in intelligence, which appeared in the Sunday newspaper, upset me. (The specific editorial has already been clearly identified, meaning its location in the Sunday newspaper is nonessential bonus information.)
An exception to this rule occurs if a demonstrative word like this, that, these, or those has already introduced an essential clause. To avoid repetitive phrasing, you may use which to introduce the very next clause, regardless of whether it is essential or nonessential.
That is a decision which you must live with for the rest of your life. (Using which prevents the awkward repetition of saying That is a decision that…)
Those ideas, which we’ve discussed thoroughly enough, do not need to be addressed again.
Streamlining Your Writing
As a final stylistic tip, you can often significantly streamline your writing by completely removing the word which or that. Removing these unnecessary filler words creates tighter, more professional sentences.
That is a decision which you must live with for the rest of your life. (Wordy)
That is a decision you must live with for the rest of your life. (Better)
You must live with that decision for the rest of your life. (Best)