↑
❯

English Grammar in Action, Lesson 41: Interrogatives

English Grammar in Action, Lesson 41: Interrogatives

Interrogatives are words that ask a question. They are typically placed at or near the beginning of a sentence, and that sentence ends with a question mark. Some interrogatives function as pronouns, taking the place of nouns. Specifically, the words who, whom, whose, what, and which can act as pronouns in several grammatical roles: they can serve as the subject of a sentence, a direct object, the object of a preposition, or a possessive modifier.

Subject: Who is baking in the kitchen?
Subject: Which is yours? (The noun subject is understood.)
Subject: What needs to be cleaned?
Direct object: Whom did you call this morning?
Direct object: Whose did you select? (The noun object is understood.)
Direct object: What will the children build?
Preposition: With whom were they speaking?
Preposition: From what did you derive that idea?
Preposition: In which did they invest?
Possessive: Whose car broke down? (Whose modifies car.)

Other interrogatives act as adverbs rather than pronouns. The words how, when, where, and why modify the clause to ask about manner, time, place, or reason. When answering these questions, the responses typically address these specific adverbial qualities.

Question: How did the athlete run? $\rightarrow$Possible Answer: swiftly
Question: When is the concert? $\rightarrow$Possible Answer: on Friday
Question: Where are they traveling? $\rightarrow$Possible Answer: to Italy
Question: Why is she celebrating? $\rightarrow$Possible Answer: because she passed her exam

Interrogative words can also be used as conjunctions to combine two clauses. However, you must be careful: a sentence formed by using an interrogative as a conjunction is not necessarily a question when combined with another clause. It depends entirely upon whether the overarching sentence is asking a question or making a statement. Notice the change in word order between a direct question and an interrogative clause embedded within a statement. In direct questions, the verb precedes the subject, but in an embedded interrogative clause, the verb follows the subject.

Question: Do you know who she is? $\rightarrow$Statement: Arthur told me who she is.
Question: Does he understand how it operates? $\rightarrow$Statement: I cannot explain how it operates.
Question: Who told you where it was? $\rightarrow$Statement: They couldn’t discover where it was.
Question: Can you tell me what kind of plant this is? $\rightarrow$Statement: I don’t know what kind of plant this is.

Using Interrogative Sentences

There are two primary types of interrogative sentences, and both types ask questions. The first type is called a yes-no question because the answer to such a question will naturally begin with the affirmative word yes or the negative word no. Most questions of this type begin with a form of the auxiliary verb do, following the structure: auxiliary + subject + verb + predicate + ?

Do + you + want + the keys + ?

If the main verb in a yes-no question is the verb to be or the verb to have, the question is formed simply by placing the verb before the subject of the sentence: to be/to have + subject + predicate + ? This inversion occurs across any tense. In the case of the perfect tenses or the future tense, it is the auxiliary form of the verbs to be and to have that precedes the subject.

Present: Is he ready for the flight?
Past: Was there enough water to finish the race?
Present perfect: Have you visited this gallery before?
Future: Will Dr. Evans be today’s guest speaker?

This kind of question structure, in which the verb precedes the subject, also occurs with numerous other auxiliaries and modal verbs, such as be able to, can, could, have, must, ought to, shall/will, should, and would. The pattern follows the structure: auxiliary + subject + verb form + predicate + ? Notice that these sentences often contain a second verb; the initial verb is an auxiliary, and it is followed by an infinitive or an elliptical infinitive, which omits the particle word to. With the auxiliary have, however, its tense conjugation combined with a past participle identifies the tense as present perfect, past perfect, or future perfect.

Modal: Are you able to complete the project?
Modal: Have you practiced here for very long?
Modal: Ought we to have mentioned that to the manager?
Present perfect: Has he spoken to the coordinator?
Past perfect: Had they spoken before the meeting?
Future perfect: Will she have spoken by noon?

Verbs that are not auxiliaries form questions by beginning them in the present tense with do or does, and in the past tense with did. The use of do/did does not occur in the other tenses. Since have is an auxiliary, it can be used in questions without do/did, though there is a frequent tendency to add the extra do/did auxiliary in both speech and writing. However, when using have to (which carries a meaning similar to must), you must use do/did in the present and past tenses. Auxiliaries like to want to and to like to form their present- and past-tense questions similarly using do/did, omitting the final to from the verb form when taking a direct object.

Present: Does Sarah want to go swimming?
Past: Did Sarah want to go swimming?
Present perfect: Has Sarah wanted to go swimming?
Future: Will Sarah want to go swimming?
Transitive Present: Do they like to watch classic movies?
Transitive Past: Did they like to watch classic movies?

Just as in a declarative sentence, verbs in a question can be formed in the progressive aspect, which means that they represent actions in progress or incomplete. Since the progressive form is composed of a conjugation of to be plus a present participle, and to be never forms a question with do/did, all questions that have a progressive verb will begin with the verb to be or its auxiliaries following the structure: to be + subject + present participle (-ing) + ? Note that a verb converted into its progressive form will no longer require the auxiliary do/did.

Progressive Form: Are you planning on joining the committee?
Progressive Form: Was he reading when the power failed?
Progressive Form: Have the students been studying in the library again?
Progressive Form: Will she be preparing for the audition?
Simple vs Progressive: Do you attend a local college? $\rightarrow$ Are you attending a local college?
Simple vs Progressive: Did the travelers sleep in tents? $\rightarrow$ Were the travelers sleeping in tents?

The second kind of question formation is one that begins with an interrogative word: who, what, why, how, which, or when. The rules that apply about the use of do/did in questions apply in the same way with questions that begin with an interrogative word. Yes-no questions and questions that begin with an interrogative word can be, for the most part, identical in their internal structure. This is possible because the interrogatives act as substitutes for adverbs, and since adverbs only modify, changes are not always needed structurally in a question.

Yes-No: Can she assist you? $\rightarrow$Interrogative: How can she assist you?
Yes-No: Do you dislike that food? $\rightarrow$Interrogative: Why do you dislike that food?
Yes-No: Are they arriving at the theater? $\rightarrow$Interrogative: When are they arriving at the theater?
Yes-No: Have you stored the documents? $\rightarrow$Interrogative: Where have you stored the documents?

This structural preservation is not the case, however, with who and what. These two interrogatives are actually pronouns that stand in place of a subject or an object in a sentence. When an interrogative pronoun replaces the subject, a declarative sentence is transformed into an interrogative sentence simply by swapping the subject for who or what without changing the word order or adding an auxiliary. When it replaces an object, standard subject-verb inversion and auxiliary rules apply. In formal style, a preposition is placed directly in front of whom or what, whereas in less formal style, who is often substituted for whom and the preposition is placed at the end of the sentence.

Subject: The chef is cooking. $\rightarrow$ Who is cooking?
Subject: A miracle occurred. $\rightarrow$ What occurred?
Object: They visited the artist. $\rightarrow$ Whom did they visit?
Object: He broke the vase. $\rightarrow$ What did he break?
Formal Object: I spoke with him. $\rightarrow$ With whom did I speak?
Informal Object: The cat sat on it. $\rightarrow$ What did the cat sit on?


Exercise 1: Direct Questions to Embedded Statements

Rewrite the following seven direct questions into complete, declarative textbook sentences starting with the provided phrase. Ensure you adjust the word order, tense, and auxiliary verbs correctly.

  1. Direct Question: Where is the laboratory located?
    Start with: The researcher could not explain…
  2. Direct Question: When did the concert begin?
    Start with: The audience forgot…
  3. Direct Question: Who are those new instructors?
    Start with: The dean inquired…
  4. Direct Question: How can she solve this calculation?
    Start with: The students want to know…
  5. Direct Question: What will they select for the project?
    Start with: It is difficult to predict…
  6. Direct Question: Why did the engine stop running?
    Start with: The mechanic discovered…
  7. Direct Question: Whose folder is lying on the desk?
    Start with: Nobody seems to know…

Exercise 2: Forming Yes-No and Wh- Questions

Transform the following seven declarative statements into the precise type of question indicated in the parentheses, paying close attention to auxiliary verb placement and subject-verb inversion.

  1. Statement: She has completed the assignment. (Turn into a Yes-No question)
  2. Statement: The flight arrives at six o’clock. (Turn into a Wh- question asking about time)
  3. Statement: Jonathan can speak four languages fluently. (Turn into a Yes-No question)
  4. Statement: The documents were delivered to the main office. (Turn into a Wh- question asking about place)
  5. Statement: They enjoyed the performance yesterday. (Turn into a Yes-No question)
  6. Statement: Someone broke the antique mirror. (Turn into a Wh- question asking about the subject)
  7. Statement: You are leaving the meeting early because you have an appointment. (Turn into a Wh- question asking about the reason)