↑

English Grammar in Action, Lesson 21: Present Progressive

English Grammar in Action, Lesson 21: Present Progressive

The present progressive tense consists of a present form of the helping verb be (am, is, are) followed by a present participle ending in -ing. While forming this tense is simple, using it correctly can be surprisingly difficult. In this lesson, we will explore how this tense functions for actions in progress and why it cannot be used with stative verbs.


Section 1: Actions in Progress and Subject-Verb Relationships

Around 80 percent of the time, the present progressive is used to describe an “action in progress.” This means the event takes place or progresses over a specific span of current time. This span can be very short, happening at the exact moment of speaking, or it can take place over vast periods of time.
I am just calling to say hello.
The two galaxies are passing through each other over a period of millennia.

To understand why some verbs cannot be used in this tense, we must look at how different verbs relate to their subjects. Dynamic verbs require the subject to be the active performer or “doer” of the action. Stative verbs, on the other hand, enter into a completely different relationship; they describe an ongoing condition, character trait, or state of the subject where no active work is being done.
Janet taught English in China for a few years.
Janet knows a lot about teaching English in China.

Sometimes, especially with mental or cognitive verbs, the difference is subtle. It often comes down to intention: is the subject intentionally performing a process, or is it a state they cannot choose? For example, figuring out an answer is an active process, while knowing an answer is a flat state. Therefore, we can use the progressive for the first, but not the second.
Betty is figuring out the answer to the question.


Section 2: Time Boundaries and the Progressive Trap

The second major difference between these two categories is how they relate to time. Dynamic verbs are time bound, meaning their actions always take place within a specific, restricted frame of real time. Because of this, you can naturally modify dynamic verbs with specific adverbs of time.
Jennifer bought a leather jacket last week.

Stative verbs are not time bound. They describe ongoing states that are unlimited by time, meaning they are inherently timeless. If you try to force a time limitation onto a stative verb using an adverb of time, the sentence becomes ungrammatical and nonsensical. Furthermore, some verbs can be either stative or dynamic depending on their definition. For instance, if appear means “to play a role,” it is dynamic, but if it means “to seem,” it is stative.
Jerome appeared in a Hollywood film.
Jerome appeared to be a little distracted.

This brings us to the core reason why stative verbs fail in the present progressive. Many learners assume the “progressive” aspect matches the continuous, ongoing nature of stative verbs. However, the present progressive actually introduces a self-limiting, temporary time frame. Changing a verb from the simple present to the present progressive shifts the meaning from an unlimited, permanent reality to a temporary, time-bound situation.
The Johnstons live in San Diego.
The Johnstons are living in San Diego.


EXERCISE 1

Determine whether the underlined verb in each sentence is functioning as a Dynamic verb or a Stative verb.

  1. Jerome appeared to be a little distracted by the noise outside.
  2. Farmer Brown owns five hundred acres of fertile land in Idaho.
  3. The children are opening their birthday presents as we speak.
  4. I have a reliable cell phone but no traditional landline.
  5. Frank answered the telephone on the very first ring.
  6. All of us have the catchy lyrics to that popular pop song in our heads.
  7. Jerome appeared in a famous Hollywood movie last summer.

EXERCISE 2

Circle or underline the verb form that is grammatically correct based on the stative or dynamic nature of the context.

  1. Betty ( is figuring out / is knowing ) the answer to the difficult riddle right now.
  2. We ( store / are storing ) all of our winter equipment in a commercial warehouse permanently.
  3. The tectonic plate ( is slowly diving / slowly dives ) under the continental shelf during this epoch.
  4. Right now, we ( store / are storing ) our extra gear in the garage until the renovations are finished.
  5. I ( understand / am understanding ) your point of view completely, so you don’t need to explain.
  6. The old retail shop ( belongs / is belonging ) to my grandfather’s estate.
  7. Look at the stage! The magician ( appears / is appearing ) out of thin air right now.