English Grammar Focus, Lesson 51: Substitution and Ellipsis with "Do so", "Such", and Auxiliaries
Part 1: Advanced Substitution with “Do So”
1. Replaying Action Verb Phrases
We use do so (including did so, doing so, done so) in formal spoken and written English to avoid repeating a whole action verb phrase and its complements.
- Formal Style: The team won the tournament in 2024 and looks likely to do so again this year. (do so = win the tournament)
- Informal Style: Clara waved as she drove past. She does it / that every single morning. (Using ‘do it’ or ‘do that’ is preferred in casual speech).
- Modal Alternative: “Will this software work on your laptop?” — “It should do.” (In less formal English, ‘do’ alone can stand after modals).
2. Forbidden Contexts: States and Habits
You cannot use do so to substitute for verbs that describe static conditions, feelings, or fixed habits. You must use a plain auxiliary verb or repeat the concept instead.
| Action Verbs (Do So Allowed) | Stative / Habitual Verbs (Do So Forbidden) |
|---|---|
| Focuses on a dynamic event. | Focuses on an ongoing state, emotion, or regular capability. |
| Dynamic context: 70% of the voters supported the new candidate, whereas only 50% did so last election. | Stative context: David doesn’t like social media platforms, but his brother does. (Not: …does so). |
| Dynamic context: He admitted to the break-in, though he only did so after the evidence was shown. | Habitual context: She studied significantly more than I did. (Not: …did so). |
Part 2: Categorical References with “Such”
3. Referring to Types and Kinds
We use such in formal speech and writing to mean “of this kind” or “of that kind” when looking back at a previously mentioned topic.
- With Uncountable Nouns: The students openly disrespect the staff. Such behavior is completely unacceptable. (Informal: Behavior like this…)
- With Plural Nouns: When asked about reports that the school is planning to cut ten jobs, a manager said, “I know of no such plans.” (Informal: …no plans of this kind).
- With Singular Countable Nouns (Use “Such a/an”): They needed someone who was both a skilled programmer and an inspiring leader. Such a person was difficult to find. (Informal: A person like this…)
Part 3: Verb Phrase Ellipsis Using Auxiliaries
To keep sentences scannable, we use short auxiliary verbs (be, have, do, or modals) instead of repeating the entire main verb group.
4. Multiple Auxiliaries and Single Identifiers
- Standard Auxiliary Replacement: She claims she has finished the painting, but I don’t think she has. (has = has finished it).
- Multiple Auxiliaries: If a verb group contains more than one auxiliary verb, you can keep only the first one or include two for precision.
- Short Form: “The flight could have been delayed by the heavy storm.” — “Yes, it could.”
- Extended Form: “The flight could have been delayed by the heavy storm.” — “Yes, it could have (been).”
5. Managing Forms of “Do” and “Be”
- When No Auxiliary Exists: If the original clause contains a plain present simple or past simple verb, use the correct form of do or did.
- Present Context: Mark plays soccer on weekends, and I do too.
- Past Context: “I didn’t lose the keys.” — “No one thinks you did.”
- When the Main Verb is “Be”: You must repeat a form of the verb be rather than using do.
- Context: The children are noisy again. They always are.
Part 4: Special Rules for the Verb “Have”
When substituting clauses where have or have got is the core verb, the structure depends on whether the verb describes possession or a physical action.
6. Possession vs. Action Idioms
- Possession Context (Use either): “Do you think you have a chance of winning the award?” — “Yes, I think I have.” (Or: …I think I do).
- Action Idioms (Use “Do” exclusively): When have is part of an action phrase (like have a shower, have a fight, have a good time), you must use a form of do.
- Action Context: I wasn’t expecting to have a good time at the conference, but I did. (Not: …but I had).
7. Conversational Spoken Extensions
In everyday spoken English, we add extra emphasis by dropping specific words into our auxiliary responses:
- Have + Done (Transitive Verbs Only): You can follow the have auxiliary with the word done in spoken styles, provided the hidden verb is transitive.
- Transitive: She has never made a serious mistake before. Well, she has (done) this time.
- Intransitive Restriction: They have already arrived. I don’t think they have. (Do not say “have done” here because ‘arrive’ has no object).
- Modal + Do: You can attach the word do directly after a modal auxiliary in casual speech.
- Context: “Will you be seeing Sarah today?” — “I might (do).”
- Future Aspect Alternative: You can use be instead of do if the hidden action describes a continuous future state: “Will you be seeing Sarah today?” — “I might (be).”
Part 5: Omitting “Be” in Passives and Future Clauses
8. The Informal Omission
If the verb be acts as an auxiliary verb or a main verb inside a passive clause, you can safely drop it completely after a modal auxiliary in informal speech.
- Main Verb Auxiliary: “Is Lily staying for dinner?” — “Yes, I think she will (be).” (Formal: …she will be / Informal alternative: …she will do).
- Passive Clause Context: The historic books must be preserved. I am certain they will (be).