English Grammar Focus, Lesson 45: Prepositions in Relative Clauses
Part 1: Advanced Formal Structures
1. Noun + Of Which
In formal and academic writing, the structure noun + of which is highly preferred over the alternatives whose + noun or splitting the preposition to the end of the clause.
- Formal Style (Noun + Of Which): A large volume of chemicals was spilled, the consequences of which are still being studied.
- Alternative Style (Whose + Noun): A large volume of chemicals was spilled, whose consequences are still being studied.
- Formal Style (Preposition First): The company of which he is president is expanding.
- Informal Style (Preposition Stranded): The company (that) he is president of is expanding.
2. Quantifiers and Partitives with “Of Which” and “Of Whom”
When combining relative clauses with quantity words (such as all, each, many, most, neither, none, part, some, a number, fractions, or superlatives), we must use of which (for things) or of whom (for people). Do not use which or whom by themselves here.
- With Things (Of Which): Clara was able to switch between Spanish and Italian, both of which she spoke fluently. (Rather than: …both which she spoke…)
- With People (Of Whom): The company hired ten new engineers, three of whom have advanced degrees.
Part 2: Preposition Placement and Formality Shifts
The position of a preposition completely changes the tone of a relative clause. Putting the preposition at the very start of the relative clause sounds highly formal and academic, while stranding it at the end sounds natural and conversational.
3. Strict Pronoun Constraints with Initial Prepositions
When you choose a formal style and place the preposition at the front of the relative clause, you must follow these absolute rules:
- Use “Whom”, Not “Who” for People:
- Correct: These are the clients to whom I sent the contract.
- Incorrect: These are the clients to who I sent the contract.
- Never Use “That” or Zero Pronoun After a Preposition:
- Correct: The apartment in which the student lives is very small.
- Incorrect: The apartment in that the student lives…
- Incorrect: The apartment in the student lives…
Part 3: Phrasal and Multi-Word Verbs
When the verb inside the relative clause is a multi-word phrasal verb, the position of the preposition follows strict physical limits based on the number of words in the verb.
4. Two-Word Phrasal Verbs
If the verb is a two-word phrasal verb (such as come across, fill in, look after, take on), you cannot separate the particle from the verb to place it before the pronoun. It must stay glued to the verb at the end.
- Correct Structure: The old letters, which a student came across in the library, are now safe.
- Incorrect Structure: The old letters, across which a student came in the library, are now safe.
5. Three-Word Phrasal Verbs
With three-word phrasal verbs (such as look up to, cut down on, run out of), putting the preposition before the relative pronoun sounds incredibly stiff, awkward, and overly academic. English speakers almost universally avoid this pattern.
- Natural/Standard: She is one of the supervisors who I look up to.
- Awkward/Avoid: She is one of the supervisors to whom I look up.