English Grammar Focus, Lesson 25: Wh-Questions with Who, Whom, Which, How, and Whose
Part 1: Asking About People and Identifying Groups
1. Who vs. Whom
We use who to ask about people. It can act as the subject, object, or complement of a sentence. In formal English, whom is used instead of who when it acts as the object of a verb or comes directly after a preposition.
- Who as Subject: Who opened the front door?
- Who as Object: Who did you see at the library?
- Whom as Object (Formal): Whom did you see at the library?
- Whom after Preposition (Formal): To whom were you speaking on the phone?
2. Using “Which” for People
While who is the standard choice for people, we switch to which in two specific situations:
- Identifying Someone in a Group: Use which when you want to pick out or identify a specific person from a known group or photograph.
- Example: “Which is your sister?” — “The one standing next to Sarah.”
- Comparing Classes of People: Use which instead of who when asking a question that compares distinct professions, categories, or groups of people.
- Example: Which do you think works longer hours, a doctor or a pilot?
3. Choosing “Which” Before “One” and “Of”
We regularly use which (and not who or what) right before the words one(s) or of when asking someone to make a choice between a limited set of options.
- Before “one”: I found two umbrellas. Which one belongs to you?
- Before “of”: Which of you wants to help me clean the kitchen? (Rather than: Who of you…)
Part 2: Agreement Rules for Subject Questions
4. The Singular Verb Rule
When who or what acts as the subject of a question, the verb that follows it is usually singular, even if we fully expect the answer to include a list of multiple people or things.
- Example: What is left to buy for the party? (Expects an answer like: “Apples, soda, and cake are left.” But the question verb remains singular).
- Example: Who wants a piece of cake?
5. Exceptions to the Singular Rule
The verb changes to plural in two specific structural environments:
- Echo Questions: When you repeat a question immediately after someone mentions a plural group to confirm what you heard.
- Speaker A: “My friends are waiting outside.”
- Speaker B: “Who are outside?”
- When Acting as Complements: When who or what functions as a complement looking directly at a plural noun phrase later in the sentence.
- Example: Who are those students over there?
- Example: What are the main reasons for your choice?
Part 3: How vs. What
The choice between how and what changes the type of information you are requesting. The table below outlines these distinct conversational contexts:
Everyday Idioms: “How about” and “What about”
We can use either how about or what about interchangeably in casual speech for two functions:
- Making Suggestions: How about a walk in the park? / What about a walk in the park?
- Asking for Clarification: “He looks very worried.” — “What do you mean?” / “How do you mean?“
Part 4: Asking About Ownership
6. Using “Whose”
We use whose to ask which person owns, possesses, or is responsible for a specific object or situation. It can come directly before a noun or stand alone as a pronoun before a verb.
- Before a Noun: Whose jacket is this on the chair?
- As a Pronoun: Whose are these keys on the table?