↑

English Grammar Focus, Lesson 19: Should, Ought to, and Had Better

English Grammar Focus, Lesson 19: Should, Ought to, and Had Better

Part 1: Obligations, Recommendations, and Preferences

1. General Advice and Probability

We can use either should or ought to to talk about obligations, recommendations, or things we expect to happen. In general, should is used much more frequently.

  • Obligation/Recommendation: You should finish your dinner before eating dessert. (Or: …ought to finish…)
  • Probability/Expectation: The food should be ready by now. (Or: …ought to be…)

Certainty Based on Evidence

When we look at strong evidence and conclude that something is certain or highly likely, we must use must (and not should or ought to).

  • Correct: This is the third time he has eaten at that restaurant this week. He must really like the food.
  • Incorrect: This is the third time… He should really like the food.

2. Specific Preferences for “Should”

While should and ought to often mean the same thing, we prefer should in the following four situations:

  • Outside Authorities or Manuals: Use it when citing official rulebooks, instructions, or manuals.
    • Example: The guide says that the camera should be turned off before removing the battery. (Rather than …ought to be turned off…)
  • Giving Advice with “I”: Use it in conditional structures when giving personal advice from your own perspective.
    • Example: I should leave early tomorrow if I were you. (Or: I would leave… / Never: I ought to leave… if I were you).
  • In Questions (Especially Wh- Questions): We choose should for standard questions.
    • Example: What should I do if I lose my house keys?
    • Example: Should I call your office phone later?
  • Offers and Advice Requests: Use it to offer help or ask for confirmation.
    • Example: Should I carry that heavy bag for you? (You can also use shall here with a similar meaning).

Part 2: Regrets and Past Expectations

3. Regrets and Criticisms (should/ought to have + past participle)

We use this perfect structure to talk about something that did not happen in the past, and we are now sorry or critical about it. The negative forms shouldn’t have and oughtn’t to have are almost always used this way.

  • Positive Regret (We didn’t do it, but it was a good idea):
    • We should have waited for the rain to stop before walking home. (I’m sorry we didn’t wait).
  • Negative Criticism (We did it, but it was a bad idea):
    • You shouldn’t have eaten that entire box of cookies. (You ate them, and it was a mistake).

4. Past or Present Expectations

We also use this structure to state that we fully expect an event has already happened or will be finished by now, provided everything went according to plan.

  • Example: If the bus left on time, they should have arrived at the station by now.

Part 3: Had Better vs. Should / Ought to

5. Urgent Advice in Spoken English

In daily spoken English, we use had better ('d better) followed by a bare infinitive to say that we think an action is a very good idea right now. It often carries a warning of negative consequences if the action is ignored.

  • Example: You look very sick; you**’d better see** a doctor today.
  • Negative Form: We**’d better not be** late for the morning meeting.

6. When “Had Better” Cannot Be Used

We cannot use had better for past situations or for making general commentary statements. You must use should or ought to instead.